Start here · Marketplaces · 2 August 2026
Amazon vs Flipkart vs Myntra: where should a new seller start?
Fees, buyer behaviour, RTO risk and category fit — an honest comparison for your first marketplace, with real trade-offs instead of hype.
Quick answer
For a new Indian seller, Amazon suits most general categories and offers the largest prepaid share; Flipkart reaches deeper into tier-2 and tier-3 cities but carries a heavier COD and RTO load; Myntra is fashion-only and requires brand and category approval before listing. The right first platform is the one where the category already sells well and the margin survives that platform's fee and return profile.
Every guru has a favourite answer. The honest answer is: it depends on your product, your price point and how much operational pain you can absorb in month one. Here's the trade-off map we actually use with clients.
Amazon: the deepest market, the strictest referee
Amazon has India's most valuable buyers and the best logistics (FBA). It rewards sellers who play the catalogue game well: sharp listings, reviews, ads run to a target. It also has real fees at low price points and the least forgiveness for sloppy operations — account health is a daily discipline. Start here if your product sells above roughly ₹400–500 and you can invest in doing it properly.
Flipkart: the volume machine for Bharat
Flipkart's buyer base skews value-conscious and COD-heavy, and it dominates certain categories (fashion via Myntra, general merchandise in tier-2/3 cities). Fees are broadly comparable to Amazon's; RTO risk is typically higher because of the COD share. Start here if your product is price-competitive and you have your RTO process ready from day one.
Myntra: the curated one, for fashion brands
Myntra is a curated fashion platform: onboarding is an application, not a signup, and the catalogue standards (images, size charts, attributes) are stricter than anywhere else. In return you reach buyers who arrive intending to buy apparel and accessories, at higher average price points than a general marketplace. Start here if you're building a fashion or lifestyle brand and can meet the catalogue bar — and budget for event and discount participation in your margin maths from day one.
The decision in three questions
- Price point: under ₹300, marketplace fixed fees hurt badly on Amazon — check the fee maths before you list. Above ₹500, Amazon and Flipkart open up properly.
- Category: fashion leans Myntra/Ajio; branded-feel products lean Amazon; value-led general merchandise leans Flipkart. Handmade and design-led products should also look at Etsy for international demand.
- Operational readiness: can you handle COD confirmation, returns and daily account health? If not yet, start with one marketplace, not three.
One more honest note: "be everywhere" is good advice at month twelve, not month one. Nail unit economics on one platform, then expand with a playbook — the multi-marketplace juggling act is where unmanaged accounts start leaking.
Want this done for you?
Marketplace Onboarding & GST/TCS Setup →
Once you've picked the platform, we get you listed on it cleanly — documents, approvals and configuration in the right order.
Reading about the leak is free. So is seeing yours.
The diagnosis shows your account's own numbers — leakage, wrong charges and recoverable money, in rupees. You keep the findings either way.
Diagnose my constraint →